TL;DR
The hurdle rate is the minimum rate of return on an investment or portfolio that a fund manager must achieve before being eligible to receive performance-based compensation, such as carried interest.
If the returns on the investment do not surpass the hurdle rate, the manager does not receive the performance fee.
In the context of private equity and venture capital, the hurdle rate is often set as a percentage return on the capital invested by Limited Partners (LPs).
How is the Hurdle Rate Calculated?
The hurdle rate is typically set as a percentage, reflecting the minimum acceptable return on the invested capital before the fund manager can earn performance fees.
The calculation of the hurdle rate considers several factors, including:
- Cost of Capital: The hurdle rate is often aligned with the cost of capital, which represents the minimum return required by investors to compensate for the risk of investing in the fund. This includes factors like interest rates, the risk-free rate of return, and the risk premium associated with the specific investments.
- Market Conditions: The general economic environment and prevailing market conditions play a role in determining the hurdle rate. In periods of high economic growth, the hurdle rate may be set higher to reflect greater investor expectations, whereas in a low-growth environment, it might be lower.
- Investment Strategy: Different types of funds have different risk profiles and return expectations. For example, a venture capital fund investing in early-stage startups might have a higher hurdle rate compared to a private equity fund focused on more mature companies, due to the higher risk involved.
- Investor Expectations: The expectations of the fund’s Limited Partners (LPs) regarding the return on their investment also influence the hurdle rate. If LPs expect higher returns due to the nature of the investments or the reputation of the fund manager, the hurdle rate might be set higher.
Types of Hurdle Rates
There are generally two types of hurdle rates used in investment funds:
- Soft Hurdle Rate: Under a soft hurdle rate, the fund manager earns carried interest on the entire profits once the hurdle rate is exceeded. For example, if the hurdle rate is 8%, and the fund returns 12%, the manager receives carried interest on the entire 12% return, not just the excess over the hurdle.
- Hard Hurdle Rate: In contrast, a hard hurdle rate means that the fund manager only earns carried interest on the returns above the hurdle rate. Using the same example as above, if the hurdle rate is 8% and the fund returns 12%, the manager would only earn carried interest on the 4% excess return above the 8% hurdle.
Why is the Hurdle Rate Important?
The hurdle rate is important for several reasons, both for fund managers and investors:
- Aligning Interests: The hurdle rate helps align the interests of fund managers with those of the investors. By setting a minimum return threshold, it ensures that managers are incentivized to achieve strong performance before earning additional compensation, thus protecting investor interests.
- Benchmark for Performance: The hurdle rate serves as a benchmark for evaluating the performance of the fund. It sets a clear target that the fund must meet or exceed, providing a way to measure the success of the investment strategy and the effectiveness of the fund manager.
- Risk Management: For investors, the hurdle rate reflects the minimum acceptable return for the level of risk they are taking. It helps ensure that the fund is not just achieving returns but is also compensating for the inherent risks of the investments.
- Attracting Investors: A well-defined and reasonable hurdle rate can make a fund more attractive to potential investors. It signals that the fund manager is confident in their ability to generate returns that meet or exceed the expectations of the investors.
Example of a Hurdle Rate in Action
Let’s consider a hypothetical private equity fund, VC Scoop Fund, with the following characteristics:
- Committed Capital: $100 million
- Hurdle Rate: 8%
- Carried Interest: 20% of profits above the hurdle rate
Scenario: Exceeding the Hurdle Rate
- Fund Performance: The VC Scoop Fund generates a return of $120 million after a few years of investment, resulting in a profit of $20 million.
- Hurdle Rate Calculation: The hurdle rate is 8%, so the fund needs to generate at least $8 million in profits (8% of $100 million) before the fund manager is eligible for carried interest.
- Carried Interest: Since the fund’s profits exceed the hurdle rate, the fund manager is entitled to 20% of the profits above the hurdle rate. The excess profit over the hurdle is $12 million ($20 million total profit – $8 million hurdle). The carried interest is 20% of $12 million, which equals $2.4 million.
- Investor Returns: After the carried interest is deducted, the remaining $17.6 million in profits is distributed to the investors.
Conclusion
The hurdle rate is a fundamental component of investment fund management, serving as a benchmark that ensures fund managers are incentivised to achieve strong returns for their investors.
Interested in learning more VC related terms? Head over to our VC glossary!